Surely we can’t be Serious
A podcast where real life takes a back seat to laughs, stories, and the kind of conversations you’d normally only hear at the end of a long night with friends.
Hosted by Mitch Rogers, Jim Podratsky, and Joey Brown — with producer Mike Carroll keeping the wheels on — the show proudly avoids politics, religion, and anything overly serious. Instead, the crew dives into pop culture, music, sports, nostalgia, random debates, and whatever else sparks a good time.
It’s lighthearted, unpredictable, and built on the simple idea that sometimes the best conversations are the ones that don’t matter at all.
Episodes
Apr 22, 2026
Apr 22, 2026
1 hr 13 min
This may be the best one yet... no, seriously!!!! Join Mitch, Joey and Jim on a trek to stay away from all things complicated.
Apr 20, 2026
Apr 20, 2026
1 hr 27 min
Check out the latest episode where Mitch, Joey and Jim "debate" the best bands of all time according to Rolling Stone magazine. We talk about the latest Coachella and the controversy surrounding Justin Bieber's performance. Just a couple of unserious topics discussed this week. Enjoy!
Apr 3, 2026
Apr 3, 2026
1 hr 18 min
Sit back, relax and enjoy the show. This week Mitch, Jim and Joey crown the all-time TV/Sitcom champion, break down the greatest movie plot twists and so much more. Leave the religion and politics at the door and come inside!
Mar 11, 2026
Mar 11, 2026
1 hr 19 min
If you are interested in all things not serious we are here for you. We focus on childhood heartthrobs and Saturday Morning cartoons. We go completely off the rails and we love it. Please check us out on: https://www.youtube.com/@SurelyWeCantBeSerious
Feb 20, 2026
Feb 20, 2026
1 hr 5 min
Welcome to Surely We Can’t Be Serious. Joey is living his best life on vacation this week, so stepping in to keep us in line — or at least try — Mike Carroll is back in the chair tonight. We’ll also celebrate Team USA bringing home Olympic gold in women’s hockey, pay tribute to the legendary Robert Duvall, and of course get into whatever nonsense we usually stumble into. Jump in the comments, tell us where you’re watching from, and let’s have some fun.
Feb 18, 2026
Feb 18, 2026
1 hr 30 min
Welcome to Surely We Can’t Be Serious — the podcast where we specialize in talking about absolutely nothing serious. We’re Mitch, Jim, Joey, and super producer Mike on the wheels of steel. Super Bowl, songs of the century, and more!